man Mordicai Andrews‏‎, son of Samuel Andrews and Mary Wright‏.
Born ‎11 Aug 1664 Oyster Bay Nassau County New York, died ‎19 Jun 1736 Tuckertown, NJ‎, 71 years
Who Alice Andrews father is seems to be solved. Quaker Meeting Record 1681-1935 lists children of Edward and Sarah Andrews as daughters Elizabeth, Sarah and Hannah. His Will cites "my 3 daughters, one of who is Elizabeth". That Quaker record is clear on the names of who the 3 daughters were. The question of whether it was Edward or Mordecai Andrews seems to be answered by this Quaker record and the Will of Mordecau Andrews that cites Alice Mathis as his daughter.

Married ‎14 Jul 1691 (44 years married) to:

woman Mary‏‎ Maiden name unknown alleged to be a French woman
Married name: Andrews, born ‎± 1670, died ‎1750 Little Egg Harbor, New Jersey‎, approximately 80 years


From Monmouth County New Jersey Deeds by Richard S. Hutchinson, published by Heritage Books, Inc: pg 35: (p 23) Marriage Certification 14 July 1691 - These are to certified all to whom it may concern that Mordecay Andres & Mary his wife are lawfully joyned together in wedlock according to ye appointment...this ye...(14 July 1691)

Children:

1.
woman Alice (Higbee) Andrews‏
Married name: Higbee, born ‎1695/1700 Burlington NJ, died ‎1774 Tuckertown, NJ‎, approximately 79 years, buried ‎ Friends Graveyard Tuckertown NJ
She herself is said to have been possessed of unusual business talents, ordering and arranging her affairs with utmost regularity and good judgement. It is also affired that she was a greater speculator than her husband, and it was in a measure owing to her influence and speculative passion and forethought that he became such an extensive land holder.Taking in consideration the age in which she lived and also the meager opportunities she had for acquiring knowledge she had a fair education.She wrote a better hand than her husband.She is described as a large, tall and muscular woman of dark complexion, with black hair and eyes which she inherited from her father.Alice Andrews-Higbee-Mathis was the mother in law of 2 Leedses (brothers being sons of Japheth and Deborah Leeds)through two separate marriages.As the wife of John Higbee her daughter Abigail married our Robert Leeds.As the wife of the Great John Mathis her daughter Sarah married John Leeds.
2.
man Mordicai Andrews Jr.‏
Born ‎1700, died ‎Jun / Jul 1763‎
3.
woman Edith Andrews‏
Married name: Allen
4.
woman Mary Andrews‏
Married name: Crammer