Married 16 May 1900 Seneca County Ohio to: Estella Haxton Butler, daughter of James Butler and Elizabeth Horton. Married name: Shaffer, born 17 Oct 1877 Green Point NY Horton? Children: 1. Paul Raymond ShafferBorn 18 Oct 1910 Fostroia, OH, died 3 Nov 2000 Marysville, Ohio, 90 years. Occupation: Geologist Professor 2. George B Shaffer3. Robert D Shaffer4. Esther E Shaffer |