‎woman Estella Haxton Butler‏‎, daughter of James Butler and Elizabeth Horton‏.
Married name: Shaffer, born ‎17 Oct 1877 Green Point NY
Horton?

Married ‎16 May 1900 Seneca County Ohio to:

‎man Joseph William Shaffer‏‎, son of Michael Shaffer and Mary Feidler‏.
Born ‎17 Aug 1867 Girard PA

Children:

1.
‎man Paul Raymond Shaffer‏‎
Born ‎18 Oct 1910 Fostroia, OH, died ‎3 Nov 2000 Marysville, Ohio‎, 90 years. Occupation: Geologist Professor
2.
‎man George B Shaffer‏‎
3.
‎man Robert D Shaffer‏‎
4.
‎woman Esther E Shaffer‏‎